Rating Grid

Comments to editors

  • How relevant is the topic of the article to the field?
  • Clarity of the problematic and/or research question
  • How original is the research question?
  • To what degree is the article based on sound theory?
  • How appropriate is the methodology?
  • Presentation of results (e.g. clarity, interest, etc.)
  • To what extent does the discussion yield new insights?
  • How relevant are the managerial recommandations?
  • Reviewer's recommendation
  • Final recommendation:
    1. Accept
    2. Minor revision
    3. Major revision
    4. Reject and resubmit
    5. Reject

Comment for authors

  • General comment
  • Specific comment